My dad and my girlfriend are as big of San Francisco Giants fans as I am. Maybe even bigger fans. But if there’s one problem they have with the Giants, it’s with their uniforms. Let me explain.
My dad, an illustrator, and my girlfriend, an up-and-coming hotshot designer, pay very close attention to typography (as do I). This happens everywhere. Television. The mall. Packages. Advertisements. Baseball games. So when it comes to watching our beloved Giants, my dad and my girlfriend notice one big thing:
‘GIA NTS’
Oh, the kerning. The kerning! While I acknowledge that this kerning issue exists, I think it’s irrelevant. I know what you’re thinking. “Some weird typography thing, and this designer guy says it’s irreleveant? Some kind of designer. Sheesh.” I’ll explain, after some back story.
During the baseball season, I must hear something about the uniform gap every week. “It looks like a second grader sewed these numbers on,” my dad will say. “Why don’t they go back to the old uniforms? They didn’t used to look like that.”
He’s right, of course. The Giants’ home uniforms used to employ the block/chiseled serif front without the gap.
(I want to add that it’s actually pretty odd the Giants moved away from this. Why?)
Take a look at this older production shot of former shortstop Rich Aurilia, circa ‘when he had graying facial hair’. The ‘A’ and the ‘N’ physically touch! Actually, physically touch! The ‘A’ splits the gap, and is (presumably) printed on both sides of the uniform, creating a gapless look. It looks good. And tight. Except …
This is baseball. Baseball isn’t necessarily about the looks. Baseball teams don’t need flashy uniforms, or Nike’s jersey ingenuity. Baseball teams need traditional uniforms. Classic looks. That’s why the league has moved away from the weird powder blue looks made popular (infamous?) by the Phillies. Away from the pullovers, and away from the myriad ‘alternate’ looks. Back to classic.
How’s this relate to the Giants’ kerning problems? I don’t think the kerning looks great, but I also think it would be strange to have the edge of the ‘A’ printed again, like on Aurilia’s jersey. But that’s my point: It doesn’t matter!
It doesn’t matter how the kerning is on the uniform. That’s the last thing I’m watching when I’m watching a game. Baseball is a game about getting dirty, playing with your heart, and hustling. They’re still my team, good kerning or bad.
So, ‘GIANTS’ or ‘GIA NTS’? I’ll take ’em either way.